The national media jumped all over last week’s Case-Shiller data announcement that real estate markets had dropped to 2002 pricing levels and that we were entering a “double-dip” period of the housing market decline. Bad news sells, and the media hounds were all over this one.
It’s important to look at matters like this with a sense of proper perspective. When the tide goes out, all boats ride lower in the water, but that does not mean that they all sink equally low, nor that that some won’t rise to higher levels when the tide comes back in. The current downturn is being driven by a glut of foreclosures in the broader market, and an employment market that is still weak due to the vastly improved efficiency of America’s private sector employers. The foreclosures are artificially lowering “the tide” in Lamorinda real estate, even though we have relatively few of them within our immediate market.
According to CoreLogic, national residential prices dropped 7.5% in April over April 2010 levels, yet stripped of the foreclosure sales, prices were only off one half of one percent (0.5%). In Lamorinda, the April 2011 median price was down just 2.5% from April 2010 — a much healthier performance level than the “national” markets. Ah… remember, there is NO such thing as a “national” real estate market, yet that is what the media keeps referring to in the myriad of bad news real estate articles.
It’s refreshing to see some balanced perspective in the press, for example in this past weekend’s Wall St. Journal article “Why It’s Time to Buy“. According to the article, there are numerous reasons to buy now:
- Mortgage rates at near 50 year lows, dropping to an average of 4.55% last week.
- Moody’s Analytics reporting that the ratio of home prices to income is now 20.9% lower than the 15-year average through 2010, and 12.5% lower than the 1989-2004 average.
- Nationally, Moody’s is predicting that the glut of foreclosure homes will subside by 2013, and that prices will begin edging upward then… sooner in areas such as the land of Lamorinda real estate where we have not been severely impacted by distressed properties.
- Demographic indicators such as “household formation”—the number of new households each year—are on the rise, and will take a sizable “bite” out of housing inventory… helping the “tide” to rise.








